Shoe's Pizzeria Menu (Updated September 2025)

Welcome to Shoe's Pizzeria, where every slice tells a story of passion and community! Nestled at 3300 Calumet Ave in Valparaiso, Indiana, this vibrant pizza haven is not just a restaurant; it’s a gathering place filled with warmth, laughter, and unforgettable flavors.

The menu boasts an array of delicious offerings, each crafted with care. Indulge in their New York-style pizza, known for its gooey cheese and perfectly balanced sauce. Customers rave about the hand-tossed sausage pizza and the homemade ranch dressing that elevates every bite. If you’re in the mood for something different, try the signature subs, like the Capicola or Italian Beef, all served on toasted French bread with fresh toppings.

• Wings: Don't miss the infamous 50-cent wings on Tuesdays, which patrons claim to be the best in the area.
• Beverages: Quench your thirst with a variety of drinks including Dr. Pepper and homemade fruit punch.
• Family Vibe: Known for its friendly staff and bustling atmosphere, where the owners greet you by name!

This family-friendly pizzeria stands out not just for its food but also for its commitment to customer happiness. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, Shoe's Pizzeria promises a delightful experience every time. So, gather your loved ones and take a seat at a place that feels like home!